Skip to main content
All docs

Community and feedback

Peer feedback

How to request and give peer feedback.

Peer feedback is a matched read. Another writer whose skill focus fits your piece reads it and writes back.

A reciprocal exchange

Being in the feedback queue means two things: you can request reads on your own work, and you are available to review other writers when a piece fits your skills. If you opt out of reviewing, you also step out of the request side of the queue.

You make this choice when you set up your account, and you can change it any time. Open Settings, go to Notifications, and use the Feedback exchange switch under Who can reach you. Opting out removes you from the reviewer pool and pauses your own queue requests. Direct requests to and from mutual followers are separate and keep working either way.

Requesting a read

After submitting an exercise, or from a piece’s Actions menu in your desk, select Request feedback. The system matches your piece with a writer based on the skill focus of your submission. You do not pick the reviewer. The match is automatic.

If your matched reader doesn’t respond, the piece is offered to other readers too, and anyone it was offered to can still pick it up until someone delivers. A request stays in the queue for a limited time. You get a notification when feedback is ready.

Two limits apply. The queue takes pieces up to a set length, enough for a chapter or a short story. For a whole book, send an early read to your own beta readers. For notes on one scene of a longer piece, pull that scene into its own piece and request a read on it.

The second limit is the balance. Past a monthly allowance, each read you receive has to be returned with a read you deliver before you can ask again. See The balance rule.

Sending a read directly

If you want a specific person to read your piece, you can send the request straight to someone who follows you back. In the request, choose a mutual follower under Send directly. The request goes to them instead of the shared queue. They get an in-app notification and an email that makes clear it is a personal request from you.

If you would rather not receive direct requests yourself, open Settings, go to Notifications, and turn off Allow direct feedback requests under Who can reach you. Your work can still be read through the shared queue.

What the reviewer sees

The reviewer sees your piece and a set of guided questions tied to the skill focus of the submission. The questions are optional. The reviewer writes feedback in their own words.

The guided questions change with the skill focus. For dialogue, the reviewer is asked to consider whether the dialogue reveals character. For pacing, whether the scene moves at the right speed.

Rating feedback

After you receive feedback, you can rate it with two questions: was it specific, and did it help you see something. Ratings track reviewer quality over time. They are not shown publicly.

Giving feedback

While you are in the feedback queue, pieces that fit your skill focus are offered to you to review, and reviewing is what keeps your access to the queue. Delivering feedback someone asked for earns XP, with a bonus when the writer who received it says it was helpful. That bonus arrives when they answer. Your completed feedback also counts toward the Feedback Contributor badge and the Trusted Reader badge.

The Trusted Reader badge

The Trusted Reader badge is awarded automatically for a strong record of well-rated feedback, and removed automatically if ratings drop.

For a per-kind breakdown of your reading, with its own shareable page and a downloadable certificate, see Reader credentials.

Still stuck? Head back to Support to report a bug or reach the team.